甘肅省(sheng)清鎮市市民(min)司法局(ju)

刑 事 判 決 書

（2019）黔0181刑初295號

公訴行政機(ji)(ji)關(guan)云南(nan)省(sheng)清鎮市國(guo)民檢察機(ji)(ji)關(guan)院。

被(bei)(bei)(bei)告朱貴局，小(xiao)名“小(xiao)虎虎”，男，一九九零年八月(yue)(yue)份25日出美景生，漢人(ren)，小(xiao)學生文化(hua)課，無業，戶口登記所(suo)有地河(he)南(nan)省，個(ge)人(ren)住址(zhi)同上(shang)。因犯防(fang)賊罪，于(yu)(yu)2016年的(de)5月(yue)(yue)30日被(bei)(bei)(bei)清鎮(zhen)市群眾檢察工作院判(pan)刑(xing)(xing)徒刑(xing)(xing)一三個(ge)月(yue)(yue)零五三個(ge)月(yue)(yue)，于(yu)(yu)2009年6月(yue)(yue)6日刑(xing)(xing)滿盡情釋放。涉案人(ren)詐騙尋釁(xin)滋事(shi)罪，于(yu)(yu)2015年117月(yue)(yue)31日被(bei)(bei)(bei)清鎮(zhen)市警(jing)(jing)方局刑(xing)(xing)事(shi)行(xing)政(zheng)拘留，二零一九年7月(yue)(yue)31日經清鎮(zhen)市群眾檢察工作院獲批批捕(bu)，于(yu)(yu)當(dang)日被(bei)(bei)(bei)清鎮(zhen)市警(jing)(jing)方局實行(xing)批捕(bu)，現羈押于(yu)(yu)河(he)南(nan)省清鎮(zhen)市看(kan)護所(suo)。

授權(quan)委托辯(bian)護人人劉(liu)莉，云南省唐德北(bei)(bei)京(jing)(jing)律師(shi)助(zhu)理(li)(li)事務管理(li)(li)所北(bei)(bei)京(jing)(jing)律師(shi)助(zhu)理(li)(li)。

執(zhi)行命(ming)令(ling)人孫xx，舊名稱申(shen)建祥，綽(chuo)號(hao)“孫老二”，男，1986年(nian)16月(yue)11觀生(sheng)，維族(zu)，初中文化(hua)課，無業，戶口(kou)戶籍歸(gui)屬地河南(nan)省，現住(zhu)河南(nan)省。因設嫌尋釁滋事(shi)罪，于2016年(nian)116月(yue)31日(ri)被清鎮市(shi)公安(an)部門(men)人員(yuan)局刑事(shi)扣留，去年(nian)的6月(yue)31日(ri)經清鎮市(shi)國民檢察(cha)工作院許可批捕，于即日(ri)被清鎮市(shi)公安(an)部門(men)人員(yuan)局執(zhi)行命(ming)令(ling)批捕，現羈押于河南(nan)省清鎮市(shi)看管(guan)所。

辯護人(ren)林某某，俗名(ming)陳家偉，男，1994年4月(yue)12日出美景生，民族，小升初(chu)人(ren)文，無業，戶口所住地(di)廣西省，通訊(xun)地(di)址(zhi)同(tong)上。因案發后尋(xun)釁滋事罪，于(yu)(yu)20207月(yue)19日被清(qing)(qing)鎮市(shi)(shi)(shi)公安人(ren)員部門(men)局(ju)刑事拘押，同(tong)一天7月(yue)31日經清(qing)(qing)鎮市(shi)(shi)(shi)老百姓(xing)檢察機關院(yuan)許可(ke)提(ti)起公訴，于(yu)(yu)隔日被清(qing)(qing)鎮市(shi)(shi)(shi)公安人(ren)員部門(men)局(ju)實施提(ti)起公訴，現羈押于(yu)(yu)廣西省清(qing)(qing)鎮市(shi)(shi)(shi)把守所。

實施(shi)人劉(liu)某(mou)(mou)某(mou)(mou)某(mou)(mou)，學名劉(liu)從巖，男，1995年(nian)1年(nian)初12觀生，漢族人，小學傳統文化，無業，戶(hu)(hu)口戶(hu)(hu)籍所(suo)以地云南省(sheng)省(sheng)，居(ju)住地址(zhi)同上。因被訴尋釁滋事罪，于(yu)201七年(nian)1二月31日被清(qing)(qing)(qing)鎮市派出所(suo)局(ju)刑事扣留，2018年(nian)初31日經清(qing)(qing)(qing)鎮市我們(men)檢察工作院獲準抓捕，于(yu)第二天被清(qing)(qing)(qing)鎮市派出所(suo)局(ju)實施(shi)抓捕，現羈(ji)押于(yu)云南省(sheng)省(sheng)清(qing)(qing)(qing)鎮市把守(shou)所(suo)。

四川省清(qing)鎮(zhen)(zhen)市各(ge)族(zu)民眾檢(jian)查機關工(gong)作院以清(qing)檢(jian)一(yi)步刑(xing)(xing)訴(su)(su)〔2019〕362號(hao)打官司書控告執行(xing)人孫xx、朱(zhu)xx、劉xx、陳xx犯尋釁滋事罪一(yi)案(an)(an)(an)(an)，于(yu)20185月(yue)20日向該院談到(dao)公(gong)訴(su)(su)，該院授理后，實(shi)用簡宜程序流程圖(tu)，獨任案(an)(an)(an)(an)件(jian)(jian)(jian)案(an)(an)(an)(an)件(jian)(jian)(jian)審(shen)理案(an)(an)(an)(an)件(jian)(jian)(jian)，于(yu)20185月(yue)24日信息(xi)公(gong)開宣判實(shi)施了案(an)(an)(an)(an)件(jian)(jian)(jian)案(an)(an)(an)(an)件(jian)(jian)(jian)審(shen)理案(an)(an)(an)(an)件(jian)(jian)(jian)。清(qing)鎮(zhen)(zhen)市各(ge)族(zu)民眾檢(jian)查機關工(gong)作院委派(pai)檢(jian)查機關工(gong)作員趙麗娜出庭幫到(dao)公(gong)訴(su)(su)，執行(xing)人朱(zhu)xx、孫xx、陳xx、劉xx及辨(bian)護人劉莉到(dao)庭繳納訴(su)(su)訟程序。清(qing)鎮(zhen)(zhen)市社會道德解(jie)釋救助(zhu)機構(gou)委派(pai)四川達德刑(xing)(xing)事辯護律(lv)師業務所李某刑(xing)(xing)事辯護律(lv)師為孫xx、劉xx、陳xx保證社會道德解(jie)釋救助(zhu)幫到(dao)，本套案(an)(an)(an)(an)例即(ji)將案(an)(an)(an)(an)件(jian)(jian)(jian)案(an)(an)(an)(an)件(jian)(jian)(jian)審(shen)理案(an)(an)(an)(an)件(jian)(jian)(jian)終止。

庭審直(zhi)播中，公訴(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)宣讀文件了(le)起訴(su)書指(zhi)證(zheng)(zheng)的(de)(de)刑(xing)事(shi)(shi)犯(fan)罪實際上(shang)，展示了(le)抓捕路經、戶籍地消息、車(che)間照片圖(tu)片兒、指(zhi)認(ren)照片圖(tu)片兒、刑(xing)事(shi)(shi)判(pan)決(jue)書書、體(ti)諒(liang)書、目(mu)擊證(zheng)(zheng)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)顧某(mou)2、丁(ding)某(mou)幾(ji)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)證(zheng)(zheng)言、被(bei)(bei)害案人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)楊某(mou)、王(wang)某(mou)幾(ji)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)闡(chan)述、被(bei)(bei)上(shang)訴(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)孫(sun)收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)、朱收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)、劉(liu)(liu)收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)、王(wang)收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)的(de)(de)訊問筆(bi)錄(lu)與(yu)辯(bian)護、刑(xing)事(shi)(shi)評定(ding)提出的(de)(de)指(zhi)導意(yi)見(jian)書、涉案人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)員用品定(ding)位評估提出的(de)(de)指(zhi)導意(yi)見(jian)書、車(che)間勘驗筆(bi)錄(lu)、辨別筆(bi)錄(lu)等憑證(zheng)(zheng)。應應當按照《中國(guo)國(guo)中國(guo)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)民中華共和國(guo)刑(xing)法典》第二(er)點百一(yi)百三十(shi)四條一(yi)、款之規定(ding)標準，以尋釁滋事(shi)(shi)罪起訴(su)被(bei)(bei)上(shang)訴(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)孫(sun)收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)、朱收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)、劉(liu)(liu)收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)、王(wang)收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)的(de)(de)構成犯(fan)罪事(shi)(shi)故。被(bei)(bei)上(shang)訴(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)朱收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)系累犯(fan)，依法行(xing)政從重處理。被(bei)(bei)上(shang)訴(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)朱收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)、孫(sun)收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)的(de)(de)近親屬已(yi)陪嘗清鎮市麥霸純凱KTV的(de)(de)經濟損(sun)失(shi)，授予了(le)體(ti)諒(liang)，四被(bei)(bei)上(shang)訴(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)認(ren)罪狀(zhuang)態最(zui)好，可酌情從輕處理。意(yi)見(jian)對被(bei)(bei)上(shang)訴(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)朱收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)、孫(sun)收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)、王(wang)收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)、劉(liu)(liu)收(shou)(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)(xi)在(zai)刑(xing)期(qi)二(er)年有以下定(ding)罪量刑(xing)。

反訴(su)人孫XX、朱XX、陳(chen)XX公戶訴(su)機(ji)關(guan)事業單(dan)位反訴(su)誣陷的犯案事及定刑意見(jian)均(jun)一(yi)樣議，認罪。

起(qi)(qi)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)朱我司的(de)(de)辯(bian)解人(ren)(ren)(ren)要求詳細辯(bian)解意見推薦 ：1.起(qi)(qi)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)朱我司包括從犯(fan)(fan)；2.起(qi)(qi)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)朱我司事(shi)供詞(ci)犯(fan)(fan)罪分子事(shi)、主觀意圖惡(e)性腫瘤往往并(bing)不大，有(you)(you)認罪、悔(hui)罪情況；3.這個案(an)(an)子中受害(hai)人(ren)(ren)(ren)害(hai)己顧(gu)某1對的(de)(de)案(an)(an)子的(de)(de)形成(cheng)含有(you)(you)一段的(de)(de)犯(fan)(fan)錯；4.受害(hai)人(ren)(ren)(ren)害(hai)己為(wei)略微(wei)傷，已賠(pei)償金音樂酒吧(ba)海損且完成(cheng)KTV的(de)(de)體諒(liang)，推薦 對起(qi)(qi)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)朱我司在(zai)一個月低于緩刑或批捕定刑。

原告(gao)劉(liu)XX對(dui)公的訴(su)部門反(fan)訴(su)誣陷(xian)的犯罪(zui)行為客觀及定罪(zui)推(tui)薦均一樣議，認罪(zui)。辯稱自家到(dao)診所開展后，是主動的到(dao)警務部門的，都具有投案(an)劇(ju)情。

經(jing)(jing)(jing)審核(he)核(he)實：2015年(nian)(nian)11年(nian)(nian)初(chu)25日21時左(zuo)右(you)，犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)孫(sun)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)、朱(zhu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)、劉(liu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)、陳上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)、萬某(mou)(mou)(mou)（在(zai)(zai)逃(tao)(tao)）抓捕在(zai)(zai)清鎮市(shi)麥霸KTV的(de)(de)(de)(de)A328KTV內酒后，犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)朱(zhu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)的(de)(de)(de)(de)女同學(xue)高(gao)某(mou)(mou)(mou)介紹的(de)(de)(de)(de)作個叫馮某(mou)(mou)(mou)的(de)(de)(de)(de)女士。在(zai)(zai)酒后路(lu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)馮某(mou)(mou)(mou)與(yu)犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)孫(sun)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)有摟抱(bao)、玩(wan)(wan)曖(ai)昧儀態。時，犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)顧(gu)某(mou)(mou)(mou)1與(yu)此家屬(shu)亦在(zai)(zai)麥霸KTV酒后、ktv唱(chang)歌，顧(gu)某(mou)(mou)(mou)1微信營銷邀(yao)約(yue)話術馮某(mou)(mou)(mou)到(dao)A322KTV玩(wan)(wan)，后馮某(mou)(mou)(mou)帶高(gao)某(mou)(mou)(mou)到(dao)A322KTV。26日零晨0時左(zuo)右(you)，犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)孫(sun)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)公(gong)廁(ce)時中(zhong)知道馮某(mou)(mou)(mou)與(yu)顧(gu)某(mou)(mou)(mou)1儀態恩(en)愛(ai)后，做好準備沖進A322KTV打人(ren)(ren)(ren)視頻，犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)朱(zhu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)以見，便與(yu)犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)孫(sun)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)一(yi)(yi)并相撞(zhuang)A322KTV門(men)(men)，KTV內的(de)(de)(de)(de)王(wang)某(mou)(mou)(mou)、顧(gu)某(mou)(mou)(mou)1抓捕遂將(jiang)大門(men)(men)抵住。犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)孫(sun)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)見推不(bu)打開門(men)(men)，便買(mai)來(lai)碑酒瓶已經(jing)(jing)(jing)砸(za)門(men)(men)，好了(le)犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)朱(zhu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)、陳上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)、劉(liu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)、萬某(mou)(mou)(mou)（在(zai)(zai)逃(tao)(tao)）也來(lai)解決，邊相撞(zhuang)、腳踢大門(men)(men)邊砸(za)門(men)(men)。其間，犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)劉(liu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)用同一(yi)(yi)個碑酒瓶砸(za)中(zhong)我站在(zai)(zai)KTV外的(de)(de)(de)(de)楊某(mou)(mou)(mou)右(you)面部皮膚(fu)。在(zai)(zai)將(jiang)KTV門(men)(men)的(de)(de)(de)(de)窗鋼化(hua)玻(bo)璃(li)紙窗砸(za)破后相應精誠(cheng)團結推廣KTV門(men)(men)的(de)(de)(de)(de)時中(zhong)，犯罪(zui)嫌(xian)(xian)疑(yi)(yi)人(ren)(ren)(ren)陳上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)、朱(zhu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)、孫(sun)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)、劉(liu)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)級領(ling)(ling)導(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)(dao)已經(jing)(jing)(jing)往A322KTV內扔碑酒瓶，進而會造成顧(gu)某(mou)(mou)(mou)1、王(wang)某(mou)(mou)(mou)抓捕負(fu)傷(shang)(shang)及(ji)(ji)A322KTV的(de)(de)(de)(de)KTV門(men)(men)窗鋼化(hua)玻(bo)璃(li)紙窗及(ji)(ji)墻(qiang)面上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)被(bei)(bei)砸(za)壞。2015年(nian)(nian)11年(nian)(nian)初(chu)29日，經(jing)(jing)(jing)云(yun)(yun)南(nan)省(sheng)中(zhong)一(yi)(yi)檢察機(ji)(ji)關機(ji)(ji)關檢測(ce)(ce)中(zhong)央(yang)檢測(ce)(ce)，被(bei)(bei)檢測(ce)(ce)人(ren)(ren)(ren)顧(gu)某(mou)(mou)(mou)1的(de)(de)(de)(de)手部意(yi)外屬(shu)較(jiao)輕(qing)(qing)傷(shang)(shang)；去年(nian)(nian) 初(chu)3日，經(jing)(jing)(jing)云(yun)(yun)南(nan)省(sheng)中(zhong)一(yi)(yi)檢察機(ji)(ji)關機(ji)(ji)關檢測(ce)(ce)中(zhong)央(yang)檢測(ce)(ce)，被(bei)(bei)檢測(ce)(ce)人(ren)(ren)(ren)楊某(mou)(mou)(mou)的(de)(de)(de)(de)影響數量屬(shu)較(jiao)輕(qing)(qing)傷(shang)(shang)；去年(nian)(nian) 初(chu)11日，經(jing)(jing)(jing)云(yun)(yun)南(nan)省(sheng)中(zhong)一(yi)(yi)檢察機(ji)(ji)關機(ji)(ji)關檢測(ce)(ce)中(zhong)央(yang)檢測(ce)(ce)，被(bei)(bei)檢測(ce)(ce)人(ren)(ren)(ren)王(wang)某(mou)(mou)(mou)的(de)(de)(de)(de)擠壓傷(shang)(shang)數量屬(shu)較(jiao)輕(qing)(qing)傷(shang)(shang)；2015年(nian)(nian)11年(nian)(nian)初(chu)28日，經(jing)(jing)(jing)清鎮市(shi)價格(ge)認正中(zhong)央(yang)檢測(ce)(ce)，被(bei)(bei)已損壞的(de)(de)(de)(de)門(men)(men)里(li)槽窗鋼化(hua)玻(bo)璃(li)紙窗、墻(qiang)面上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)大理市(shi)石、走(zou)道窗鋼化(hua)玻(bo)璃(li)紙窗共(gong)有交換價值人(ren)(ren)(ren)們幣2020。

另查實(shi)，上訴(su)人(ren)(ren)孫收(shou)悉某、朱收(shou)悉某201七(qi)年(nian)(nian)1二(er)(er)月(yue)(yue)(yue)26日(ri)(ri)被(bei)清(qing)鎮市派出(chu)所局(ju)懲處(chu)行政管理拘役(yi)第十三日(ri)(ri)（自201七(qi)年(nian)(nian)1二(er)(er)月(yue)(yue)(yue)26日(ri)(ri)至去年(nian)(nian) 一(yi)(yi)月(yue)(yue)(yue)10日(ri)(ri)），201七(qi)年(nian)(nian)1二(er)(er)月(yue)(yue)(yue)26日(ri)(ri)，清(qing)鎮市拘役(yi)所給(gei)予實(shi)施，201七(qi)年(nian)(nian)1二(er)(er)月(yue)(yue)(yue)31日(ri)(ri)轉換成刑事(shi)拘役(yi)。上訴(su)人(ren)(ren)朱收(shou)悉某因犯防(fang)賊罪，于201四年(nian)(nian)2月(yue)(yue)(yue)30日(ri)(ri)被(bei)東大整形判刑無期徒刑大半年(nian)(nian)零三個月(yue)(yue)(yue)左右，于2017年(nian)(nian)2月(yue)(yue)(yue)6日(ri)(ri)刑滿發出(chu)。上訴(su)人(ren)(ren)孫收(shou)悉某的(de)親人(ren)(ren)陪嘗清(qing)鎮市麥(mai)霸純凱舞(wu)(wu)廳(ting)市民幣200元。去年(nian)(nian) 一(yi)(yi)月(yue)(yue)(yue)19日(ri)(ri)，該舞(wu)(wu)廳(ting)開具包(bao)容(rong)(rong)書，對朱收(shou)悉某、孫收(shou)悉某的(de)行為舉動給(gei)予包(bao)容(rong)(rong)。

作出(chu)事(shi)情(qing)，有經(jing)開庭(ting)審判(pan)(pan)舉證責任、質(zhi)證的(de)敘述物證否認：1.批捕選擇性書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)、受(shou)案(an)登記(ji)卡表、查(cha)獲經(jing)過了；2.制(zhi)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)人(ren)(ren)(ren)劉(liu)收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)、孫收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)、陳(chen)收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)、朱收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)的(de)的(de)供述與狡辯；3.受(shou)害命(ming)楊(yang)某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)、李某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)、顧(gu)某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)1的(de)描述；4.目擊證人(ren)(ren)(ren)顧(gu)某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)2、丁某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)、陳(chen)發(fa)(fa)喜、馮(feng)某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)、曾某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)、高某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)、常某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)證言；5.楊(yang)某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)及制(zhi)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)人(ren)(ren)(ren)孫收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)、陳(chen)收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)、朱收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)、劉(liu)收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)的(de)分辨筆(bi)錄；6.直(zhi)(zhi)播報(bao)道報(bao)道勘驗(yan)筆(bi)錄、直(zhi)(zhi)播報(bao)道報(bao)道八卦(gua)方(fang)位關心圖、案(an)得知場報(bao)道報(bao)道相(xiang)冊(ce)(ce)圖片(pian)(pian)頭(tou)像(xiang)(xiang)、歌廳門被破壞直(zhi)(zhi)播報(bao)道報(bao)道相(xiang)冊(ce)(ce)圖片(pian)(pian)；7.受(shou)害命(ming)李某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)、顧(gu)某(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)(mou)1撞傷(shang)相(xiang)冊(ce)(ce)圖片(pian)(pian)；8.制(zhi)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)人(ren)(ren)(ren)陳(chen)收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)、朱收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)、劉(liu)收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)、孫收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)指認直(zhi)(zhi)播報(bao)道報(bao)道相(xiang)冊(ce)(ce)圖片(pian)(pian)頭(tou)像(xiang)(xiang)；9.（2014）清(qing)刑初字(zi)第83-6刑事(shi)裁定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)、（2015）金西獄字(zi)第25-6緩解壓(ya)力判(pan)(pan)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)；10.市(shi)場價(jia)(jia)單、委托(tuo)授權(quan)代理(li)書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)、清(qing)鎮(zhen)市(shi)價(jia)(jia)格安全認證心中(zhong)清(qing)價(jia)(jia)認涉字(zi)（2018）899號涉案(an)人(ren)(ren)(ren)員(yuan)產品(pin)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)價(jia)(jia)判(pan)(pan)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)看法(fa)書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)；11.評(ping)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)會(hui)會(hui)委托(tuo)授權(quan)代理(li)書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)，安徽中(zhong)一刑事(shi)評(ping)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)會(hui)會(hui)心中(zhong)檢案(an)號為(wei)2018-5537、2019-0076、2018-5528刑事(shi)評(ping)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)會(hui)會(hui)看法(fa)書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)、評(ping)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)會(hui)會(hui)看法(fa)控(kong)制(zhi)書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)；12.使(shi)用(yong)(yong)物證請單、病例及專(zhuan)用(yong)(yong)發(fa)(fa)票(piao)；13.追償權(quan)書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)；14.四制(zhi)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)人(ren)(ren)(ren)戶口(kou)的(de)信息；15.短視頻光碟(die)、短視頻監(jian)督高清(qing)截圖相(xiang)冊(ce)(ce)圖片(pian)(pian)頭(tou)像(xiang)(xiang)；16.制(zhi)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)人(ren)(ren)(ren)孫收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)、朱收(shou)(shou)悉(xi)(xi)(xi)的(de)財政處理(li)選擇性書(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)(shu)、財政處理(li)直(zhi)(zhi)接(jie)告(gao)訴筆(bi)錄、制(zhi)定(ding)(ding)(ding)(ding)回執(zhi)、現象介紹等。

關羽民事(shi)案件爭端(duan)亮點(dian)：

一、本院認(ren)為(wei)四被上訴(su)人(ren)是(shi)否有分辯主從(cong)作用？

尋釁(xin)滋事罪侵犯名(ming)譽權的(de)(de)客(ke)體(ti)是共公治安。此案中答(da)辯(bian)(bian)(bian)人(ren)(ren)(ren)孫xx喝(he)酒因私排解的(de)(de)情緒，何(he)事生(sheng)非，在麥霸KTV包廂外與同案答(da)辯(bian)(bian)(bian)人(ren)(ren)(ren)朱(zhu)xx、劉xx、陳xx施用黑啤瓶砸門，造3名(ming)遇害(hai)人(ren)(ren)(ren)害(hai)己輕度損(sun)害(hai)麥霸KTV包廂門槽有機玻(bo)璃紙(zhi)(zhi)、樓體(ti)、走(zou)道(dao)有機玻(bo)璃紙(zhi)(zhi)被(bei)破壞的(de)(de)效果。時，造朋友(you)們圍觀者。四答(da)辯(bian)(bian)(bian)客(ke)戶(hu)某(mou)個(ge)范罪操作過程中，無約(yue)會(hui)、職責分工活(huo)動，的(de)(de)作用比(bi)較，雙方妨礙了市場共公治安。本校(xiao)因為(wei)，對(dui)四答(da)辯(bian)(bian)(bian)人(ren)(ren)(ren)系雙方范罪，但最好不要判斷主從認知度。答(da)辯(bian)(bian)(bian)人(ren)(ren)(ren)對(dui)于答(da)辯(bian)(bian)(bian)人(ren)(ren)(ren)朱(zhu)xx系從犯的(de)(de)答(da)辯(bian)(bian)(bian)意見建(jian)議，不會(hui)給予采(cai)用。

二、這個案子中(zhong)執行人劉某有(you)沒(mei)定義投案？

通過此案查獲經由、四辯(bian)(bian)護人(ren)的(de)傳(chuan)喚(huan)(huan)筆錄與狡(jiao)辯(bian)(bian)等直(zhi)接證據表現(xian)，派出(chu)所(suo)危險行政機關已(yi)經和201七年16月(yue)26晚霞(xia)警并知(zhi)道此案常(chang)見的(de)暴力犯罪(zui)真實(shi)，因辯(bian)(bian)護人(ren)劉張(zhang)某(mou)損傷(shang)要(yao)求到(dao)醫院醫生療(liao)法(fa)，派出(chu)所(suo)危險行政機關仍沒(mei)有(you)當天傳(chuan)喚(huan)(huan)辯(bian)(bian)護人(ren)劉張(zhang)某(mou)開展(zhan)調察，辯(bian)(bian)護人(ren)劉張(zhang)某(mou)的(de)罪(zui)刑雖(sui)被(bei)發(fa)現(xian)，但(dan)并沒(mei)有(you)面臨傳(chuan)喚(huan)(huan)、未被(bei)制定強迫舉(ju)措的(de)情況下，于201七年16月(yue)31日有(you)經派出(chu)所(suo)協(xie)警電話(hua)找話(hua)題后全自動到(dao)案容忍傳(chuan)喚(huan)(huan)，事先(xian)傳(chuan)喚(huan)(huan)筆錄個人(ren)的(de)罪(zui)刑，系信用卡詐騙。辯(bian)(bian)護人(ren)劉張(zhang)某(mou)的(de)狡(jiao)辯(bian)(bian)具體意(yi)見，東大整形酌情采取。

本(ben)校判(pan)(pan)定(ding)(ding)(ding)，上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)孫某(mou)(mou)個喝酒(jiu)因私(si)自我安慰情(qing)(qing)(qing)感，伙同上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)朱(zhu)某(mou)(mou)個、劉某(mou)(mou)個、林某(mou)(mou)個在公(gong)(gong)(gong)用(yong)場(chang)地(di)何(he)事(shi)生非，致同班輕(qing)(qing)柔傷，四上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)的(de)(de)形為(wei)表(biao)現(xian)擾(rao)亂(luan)單位市(shi)場(chang)交(jiao)(jiao)通(tong)有(you)序(xu)了時代公(gong)(gong)(gong)用(yong)市(shi)場(chang)交(jiao)(jiao)通(tong)有(you)序(xu)，應按(an)照(zhao)(zhao)法(fa)(fa)律指(zhi)(zhi)定(ding)(ding)(ding)組成(cheng)尋釁滋事(shi)罪(zui)，應按(an)照(zhao)(zhao)法(fa)(fa)律指(zhi)(zhi)定(ding)(ding)(ding)還應獎罰(fa)。上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)朱(zhu)某(mou)(mou)個系(xi)累犯(fan)(fan)，應按(an)照(zhao)(zhao)法(fa)(fa)律指(zhi)(zhi)定(ding)(ding)(ding)酌(zhuo)情(qing)(qing)(qing)從(cong)重獎罰(fa)。上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)劉某(mou)(mou)個系(xi)判(pan)(pan)刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)，可(ke)(ke)(ke)從(cong)輕(qing)(qing)獎罰(fa)。上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)孫某(mou)(mou)個、朱(zhu)某(mou)(mou)個子(zi)女已(yi)賠(pei)嘗清鎮市(shi)麥霸KTV的(de)(de)損(sun)害，并達成(cheng)了包容，可(ke)(ke)(ke)酌(zhuo)情(qing)(qing)(qing)從(cong)輕(qing)(qing)獎罰(fa)。公(gong)(gong)(gong)訴(su)(su)政(zheng)府機關誣陷上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)訴(su)(su)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)孫某(mou)(mou)個、朱(zhu)某(mou)(mou)個、劉某(mou)(mou)個、林某(mou)(mou)個犯(fan)(fan)尋釁滋事(shi)罪(zui)犯(fan)(fan)案(an)(an)形為(wei)籌建(jian)，本(ben)校酌(zhuo)情(qing)(qing)(qing)的(de)(de)支持。定(ding)(ding)(ding)罪(zui)量刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)意(yi)見表(biao)和建(jian)議(yi)當(dang)，本(ben)校酌(zhuo)情(qing)(qing)(qing)采用(yong)。辨護人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)所提從(cong)犯(fan)(fan)、受害命(ming)有(you)著錯誤的(de)(de)辨護意(yi)見表(biao)，于法(fa)(fa)無(wu)據(ju)，未予采用(yong)。據(ju)圖，應按(an)照(zhao)(zhao)《我國(guo)我們中(zhong)華民(min)國(guo)憲法(fa)(fa)刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)法(fa)(fa)典》第(di)五百八十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)四四條線(xian)一(yi)(yi)種(zhong)(zhong)有(you)中(zhong)所尋釁滋事(shi)形為(wei)表(biao)現(xian)這其中(zhong)之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)一(yi)(yi)，可(ke)(ke)(ke)怕破(po)壞時代市(shi)場(chang)交(jiao)(jiao)通(tong)有(you)序(xu)的(de)(de)，處十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)年下(xia)徒(tu)刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)、批捕也(ye)可(ke)(ke)(ke)能(neng)(neng)管控：（一(yi)(yi)）所以(yi)圍(wei)(wei)毆自已(yi)，情(qing)(qing)(qing)景(jing)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)分極端(duan)(duan)與(yu)惡劣的(de)(de)；（二）追(zhui)趕(gan)、過濾、侮罵、騷擾(rao)自已(yi)，情(qing)(qing)(qing)景(jing)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)分極端(duan)(duan)與(yu)惡劣的(de)(de)；（三）強拿(na)硬(ying)要也(ye)可(ke)(ke)(ke)能(neng)(neng)任何(he)毀損(sun)、損(sun)壞公(gong)(gong)(gong)私(si)財產，情(qing)(qing)(qing)景(jing)可(ke)(ke)(ke)怕的(de)(de)；（四）在公(gong)(gong)(gong)用(yong)場(chang)地(di)圍(wei)(wei)觀者鬧事(shi)，有(you)公(gong)(gong)(gong)用(yong)場(chang)地(di)市(shi)場(chang)交(jiao)(jiao)通(tong)有(you)序(xu)可(ke)(ke)(ke)怕亂(luan)七(qi)八糟的(de)(de)。”、第(di)五十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)四條一(yi)(yi)種(zhong)(zhong)“主體犯(fan)(fan)案(an)(an)叫做(zuo)同班之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)主體被人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)犯(fan)(fan)案(an)(an)。”、第(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)六十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)四條一(yi)(yi)種(zhong)(zhong)“判(pan)(pan)處徒(tu)刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)法(fa)(fa)的(de)(de)犯(fan)(fan)案(an)(an)碳原(yuan)子(zi)，刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)法(fa)(fa)連(lian)接(jie)完成(cheng)后也(ye)可(ke)(ke)(ke)能(neng)(neng)赦免的(de)(de)時候，在十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)年以(yi)下(xia)再犯(fan)(fan)酌(zhuo)情(qing)(qing)(qing)判(pan)(pan)徒(tu)刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)上(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)(shang)刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)法(fa)(fa)之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)罪(zui)的(de)(de)，是(shi)(shi)累犯(fan)(fan)，酌(zhuo)情(qing)(qing)(qing)從(cong)重獎罰(fa)，并且(qie)問題犯(fan)(fan)案(an)(an)和不足十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)九18歲(sui)的(de)(de)人(ren)(ren)(ren)(ren)犯(fan)(fan)案(an)(an)的(de)(de)不在其內。”第(di)十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)六十(shi)(shi)(shi)(shi)六條一(yi)(yi)種(zhong)(zhong)“犯(fan)(fan)案(an)(an)的(de)(de)時候全自動(dong)投案(an)(an)，事(shi)實訊(xun)問筆錄自我的(de)(de)罪(zui)名的(de)(de)，是(shi)(shi)判(pan)(pan)刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)。在判(pan)(pan)刑(xing)(xing)(xing)(xing)的(de)(de)犯(fan)(fan)案(an)(an)碳原(yuan)子(zi)，可(ke)(ke)(ke)能(neng)(neng)從(cong)輕(qing)(qing)也(ye)可(ke)(ke)(ke)能(neng)(neng)改善獎罰(fa)。這其中(zhong)，犯(fan)(fan)案(an)(an)較小的(de)(de)，可(ke)(ke)(ke)能(neng)(neng)免去獎罰(fa)。”之(zhi)(zhi)(zhi)指(zhi)(zhi)定(ding)(ding)(ding)，判(pan)(pan)決書以(yi)下(xia)的(de)(de)：

一、執行人朱某人犯尋釁滋(zi)事(shi)罪，被判徒刑年(nian) 二個(ge)月(yue)時間。

（刑(xing)期從宣判(pan)審理之時起計算(suan)公式，羈押每(mei)日(ri)(ri)折抵刑(xing)期每(mei)日(ri)(ri)，即2017年1二月(yue)26日(ri)(ri)至20年二月(yue)25日(ri)(ri)止。）

二、被告(gao)孫某種犯尋釁滋事罪(zui)，被判無期徒刑(xing)整年。

（刑期從宣判(pan)制定(ding)哪日(ri)起算出(chu)，羈押(ya)一(yi)天折抵刑期一(yi)天，即2017年15月(yue)26日(ri)至(zhi)去年 15月(yue)25日(ri)止。）

三、被告方林某某犯尋釁滋事(shi)罪，判(pan)罪無期徒刑一整年(nian)。

（刑期(qi)從判決書(shu)實施哪日(ri)起換算，羈押一周(zhou)折抵刑期(qi)一周(zhou)，即202110月19日(ri)至2O2O10月18日(ri)止。）

四、犯罪嫌疑(yi)人劉我司(si)犯尋釁滋(zi)事罪，判決緩(huan)刑10個(ge)月。

（刑期從法院判決書履(lv)行以來起計(ji)算(suan)出，羈押(ya)每(mei)(mei)周折抵刑期每(mei)(mei)周，即201八年1二月(yue)(yue)31日至今(jin)年1月(yue)(yue)30日止。）

如不公(gong)本(ben)人(ren)民(min)(min)檢(jian)察(cha)院(yuan)終審(shen)判決(jue)，可(ke)在拿到人(ren)民(min)(min)檢(jian)察(cha)院(yuan)終審(shen)判決(jue)書(shu)的(de)二是日起(qi)(qi)十日內，按照(zhao)我(wo)院(yuan)或許(xu)同時向四川省貴陽(yang)市(shi)市(shi)中(zhong)級考試公(gong)民(min)(min)人(ren)民(min)(min)檢(jian)察(cha)院(yuan)入(ru)憲起(qi)(qi)訴(su)書(shu)。予以起(qi)(qi)訴(su)書(shu)的(de)，可(ke)以提(ti)交成(cheng)功起(qi)(qi)訴(su)書(shu)狀原(yuan)本(ben)第二份，副本(ben)掉落二份。

庭審員　　盧自己

二〇一九年七月二日

副書記員　　**林

從何而來于國裁判員法律文書網